tbs_primary_yellow_white

Best Cheap Makeup on Amazon

Hey, you know us. We love bargain shopping and we’re always looking for the best cheap makeup on Amazon. Plus, Amazon is our go-to, so if we can find the best drug store beauty products under $20 on our favorite site, we are all in.

If you’re in The Bargain Sisters Group or follow @the_bargainsisters, you’ve probably seen many of these beauty products. As you know, we’re always looking for the cheapest place to buy makeup online, and if you keep your eye on Amazon, you almost always find the best beauty bargains.


Check out this list of our major drugstore must-haves that we score on Amazon and other Amazon beauty essentials we previously shared. And, be sure to keep your eye on our social channels for even better deals and discounts on all of them as they pop up!

We could sing the praises of this drugstore makeup must-have forever. Truly, it does all the things you want from your favorite mascara: it defines, volumizes, curls, and lengthens. Plus, Maybelline’s Lash Sensational Sky High mascara’s exclusive flex tower mascara brush bends to volumize and extend every single lash from root to tip. Under $9!

Maybelline Age Rewind Concealer

Best Cheap Makeup on Amazon

This concealer is praised by YouTubers and tired moms alike! It comes in a huge array of skin tones, erases dark circles and fine lines, and is infused with goji berry and Haloxyl™. Bonus: Get it on Subscribe & Save, so you never worry about forgetting it and earn extra savings. Under $7!

Rimmel Waterproof Eyeliner

Best Cheap Makeup on Amazon

It takes a very special occasion for us to swipe on eyeliner right now, but when we do, it’s this Rimmel Exaggerate Eye Definer in Blackest Black. First, we love that it’s waterproof. Second, it includes a built-in smudger and sharpener. And, third, the creamy but pigmented formula lasts up to ten hours. Best part? It’s less than $4!

Real Techniques Sponge 4-pack

Best Cheap Makeup on Amazon

Let us begin by noting that this four-pack of beauty blenders is a major beauty bargain at under $7. They’re 100% cruelty-free and vegan, are great for travel, and leave skin with a smooth and natural-looking finish. Perfect for using with liquid and cream-based makeups!

Kopari Lip Balm

Best Cheap Makeup on Amazon

We love, love, love this vegan lip gloss made with organic coconut oil. It’s truly for everyone given that it’s clear, hydrating, and moisturizing. Shave a dollar off of the $14 price tag if you add it to your Subscribe & Save!

Bamboo Reusable Makeup Remover Pads

Best Cheap Makeup on Amazon

We’ve been wanting to jump on the reusable makeup remover pad train for a while, however, it wasn’t until this past year we found some as an Amazon makeup bargain. Now, we have! These super fluffy and soft bamboo beauty pads are great for cleaning pores, cleansing skin, and appling toner. And, they come with a little bag for washing! $6.99 for 15.

Naked Eye Shadow Palette

Best Cheap Makeup on Amazon

You’ll not only get one, but TWO eye shadow palettes when you snag this Amazon makeup bargain! Plus, they’re the super-popular Naked palettes! These palettes have every color you need for every season. Go ahead, grab them for just under $14 for the bundle!

NYX Brow Glue

Best Cheap Makeup on Amazon

Brows—they can get unruly. Be confident that your brows will stay where you put them with this NYX brow glue. It’s one of our favorite Amazon makeup bargains at just $5.99! The non-sticky and transparent brow glue gives you extra strong, 16 hour extreme hold instantly. Score!

Maybelline Total Temptation Eyebrow Definer Pencil

Best Cheap Makeup on Amazon

While we’re on the subject, we haven’t been able to live without a brow pencil in recent years. If you’re in The Bargain Sisters Group, you’ve seen us post about this brow pencil a lot and it almost always sells out when we do. You’ll love the teardrop tip as well as the spoolie brush that help you shape and blend for a softly defined natural-looking brow. $7.99.

Fit Me Foundation

Best Cheap Makeup on Amazon

If you haven’t already, it’s time to convert to Maybelline’s Fit Me Foundation. It comes in 24 shades, blends beautifully, and is a total steal at under $4! It’s an even cheaper makeup deal if you add it to your Subscribe & Save.

Okay, who snagged these deals? Are there others you want to see? Don’t hesitate to comment—we’re always on the lookout for killer makeup deals for you!

Leave a Comment

The Comments

  • Alexis Jones
    January 20, 2022

    A must have for me is eye line and lip gloss

    • Cassie and Ali
      Alexis Jones
      January 20, 2022

      YES!!! Both of those are staples for us as well.

  • Marjorie
    January 20, 2022

    These are all great products. I also use a few from Wet and Wild. They have a translucent powder and a long lash mascara that are the bomb!

    • Cassie and Ali
      Marjorie
      January 20, 2022

      Wet & Wild always comes through with great options. We will have to try the mascara too! Thank you, Marjorie.

  • Cherie Riley
    January 21, 2022

    I love the eye brow defined pencil- and I found out about it from a deal on bargain Sisters!

    • Cassie and Ali
      Cherie Riley
      January 21, 2022

      We purchased it and cannot wait to try it. We love a great brow pencil to get a fluffy full brow look.

  • Cc
    February 12, 2022

    That is not urban decay naked brand eyeshadow. It’s nakeds. Beware of knock offs.

    • Cassie and Ali
      Cc
      February 18, 2022

      Yes, you are totally right! They look similar but this eyeshadow palette set is by Bestland and is a great budget-friendly alternative.